Welsh Conservatives Debate - Sustainable Farming Scheme
Motion without amendment
What this vote was about
The Conservative motion as originally written, recognising farming's importance and calling for a final, binding Senedd vote on the scheme before it starts.
The Welsh Conservatives (Paul Davies) asked the Welsh Government to hold a final, binding Senedd vote on its Sustainable Farming Scheme before it starts. Welsh Labour (Jane Hutt) proposed welcoming the scheme and noting a Statutory Instrument. The Senedd rejected both the amendment and the motion, so nothing was agreed.
The motion and amendments as published
NDM8960 Paul Davies (Preseli Pembrokeshire)
To propose that the Senedd:
1. Recognises the importance of agriculture to the Welsh economy, culture, language, environment, and rural communities.
2. Calls on the Welsh Government to bring forward a final, binding vote in the Senedd on its proposed sustainable farming scheme, prior to its implementation, to ensure democratic legitimacy, and the confidence of the agricultural sector.
Proposed Sustainable Farming Scheme Supporters
Heledd Fychan (South Wales Central)
Llyr Gruffydd (North Wales)
The following amendment was tabled:
Amendment 1 Jane Hutt (Vale of Glamorgan)
Delete point 2 and replace with:
Welcomes the proposed introduction of the Sustainable Farming Scheme; and
Notes that the Welsh Government will be bringing forward a Statutory Instrument which contains key provisions underpinning the Scheme.
For 20Against 22Abstain 0
How the chamber voted
Government position: The government voted against.
By party
| Party | For | Against | Abstain | Did not vote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Labour | 0 | 22 | 0 | 8 |
| Conservative | 11 | 0 | 0 | 4 |
| Plaid | 8 | 0 | 0 | 4 |
| Independent | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Lib Dem | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
Voted against their party
No Member voted the opposite way to their party.
How each Member voted
For20
- Andrew RT DaviesConservative
- Gareth DaviesConservative
- Paul DaviesConservative
- James EvansConservative
- Luke FletcherPlaid
- Peter FoxConservative
- Heledd FychanPlaid
- Russell GeorgeIndependent
- Tom GiffardConservative
- Peredur Owen GriffithsPlaid
- Llyr GruffyddPlaid
- Altaf HussainConservative
- Mark IsherwoodConservative
- Delyth JewellPlaid
- Laura Anne JonesConservative
- Samuel KurtzConservative
- Darren MillarConservative
- Adam PricePlaid
- Mabon ap GwynforPlaid
- Rhun ap IorwerthPlaid
Against22
- Hannah BlythynLabour
- Dawn BowdenLabour
- Jayne BryantLabour
- Hefin DavidLabour
- Rebecca EvansLabour
- Vaughan GethingLabour
- John GriffithsLabour
- Lesley GriffithsLabour
- Mike HedgesLabour
- Vikki HowellsLabour
- Huw Irranca-DaviesLabour
- Julie JamesLabour
- Jeremy MilesLabour
- Eluned MorganLabour
- Lynne NeagleLabour
- Jenny RathboneLabour
- Jack SargeantLabour
- Ken SkatesLabour
- Carolyn ThomasLabour
- Lee WatersLabour
- Joyce WatsonLabour
- Buffy WilliamsLabour
Abstain0
Did not vote18
- Mick AntoniwLabour
- Natasha AsgharConservative
- Cefin CampbellPlaid
- Alun DaviesLabour
- Jane DoddsLib Dem
- Mark DrakefordLabour
- Janet Finch-SaundersConservative
- Siân GwenllianPlaid
- Jane HuttLabour
- Joel JamesConservative
- Elin JonesPlaid
- Julie MorganLabour
- Sarah MurphyLabour
- Rhianon PassmoreLabour
- David ReesLabour
- Sam RowlandsConservative
- Sioned WilliamsPlaid
- Rhys ab OwenIndependent