Areithiau a chwestiynau

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Eurfyl, yes.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Sir Paul—

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

I just want to bring Peter in.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Lord Bourne, is there any influence that the House of Lords might have in these things, as you are a Member there?

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Sir Paul.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Sir Paul or Eurfyl. Sir Paul.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Lord Bourne, you mentioned aggregates there. Do you want to comment on that question?

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

I think this committee had a few discussions around varying income tax at the last budget round, so discourse was being had a little bit but maybe not so much making its way out of this Senedd and into public discourse and coming across. Back to you, Rhianon.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Lord Bourne.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Sir Paul or Lord Bourne, if—[Interruption.] Oh, if we do Sir Paul first, and then we'll go to Lord Bourne afterwards.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Shall we go to Eurfyl first, and then—

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Yes, that's very true, very true. I'll move on to Rhianon, then.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Thank you very much. If I ask Rhianon, if we move on, unless Sir Paul has anything to add to that discussion.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

I'm assuming then that a new formula might look at deprivation, poverty, age, all the different—. Even more so than—. So, a more dynamic formula, rather than a fairly static formula.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Okay. Thank you. And on that note, Lord Bourne, the report considered a fundamental set of principles for subnational government. How effective is that funding model in addressing these principles? So, I'm assuming it's not very.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Lovely. Thank you very much. Lord Bourne, did you have anything to add, or a different perspective?

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

No problem. Maybe if we go to Eurfyl and then maybe Lord Bourne, if—

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Lovely. Thank you very much. So, the fiscal framework, which serves to address recommendations made in your report, modify the Barnett formula for Wales to include a needs-based factor. What do you think are the advantages or the disadvantages of this model…

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Eurfyl, oes gyda chi syniadau neu sylwadau?

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Thank you very much.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

Lovely. Thank you very much. Maybe, Lord Bourne, if we come to you next, if you're—[Inaudible.]

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Y Comisiwn Silk—10 mlynedd yn ddiweddarach: Sesiwn dystiolaeth

And we'll move on to our first substantive item this morning, which is a session with members of the Silk Commission. It's 10 years on since it was published. It's a reflective session today, so it's looking back over the last 10 years and whether the areas…

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Papurau i'w nodi

Lovely. Thank you very much, we'll note that paper.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Papurau i'w nodi

I'll move on to the second item, which is papers to note. We have one paper to note.

28 Mehefin 2023, Finance Committee

Papurau i'w nodi

Felly, dwi'n mynd i symud ymlaen i eitem 2.